Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels (From Basildon Recorder)
Get involved: send your pictures, video, news and views by texting ECHONEWS to 80360, or email us »
Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels
5:00pm Wednesday 20th February 2013 in News
IMMIGRATION, teenage pregnancies and family break-ups have all been put forward as possible causes of a rise in the number of people waiting for a council house.
A full meeting of Basildon Council tried to pinpoint why more than 4,000 people are currently waiting to be housed.
The council claimed in its latest budget the building of new homes will be made a priority, although the Tory administration insist this will be in the form of “desirable family properties” and not “unattractive estates”.
Tory councillor Stephen Hillier, who represents the Langdon Hills ward, believes that a rise in immigration has caused a strain on housing demand, both locally and nationally.
Daniel Munyambu, who recently rejoined the Labour party following a spell with the Independent group, puts the problem down to both growing and disbanding families.
Basildon Council wants to ensure that any empty homes are brought up to an appropriate standard and is spending tens of millions on its housing stock over the next four years.
The cash will include £37million towards renovating properties, £1million for improving communal heating systems, £2million on general improvements to council estates, £12million a year for repairs, and £500,000 on building affordable homes.
Comments(56)
iknowbetter
says...
5:19pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Cosmo Spring wrote:Spot on, thanks to Maggie selling off the housing stock and future Governments for not building any new dwellings. Is it any wonder we are where we are.
plus the fact that after the selling off of many of them under the right to buy scheme the council haven't actually built that many, if any, new ones....
SpiffSpaffington1984
says...
5:27pm Wed 20 Feb 13
TheWizzard
says...
5:34pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Discouraged
says...
6:04pm Wed 20 Feb 13
themarinadog
says...
6:32pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Carnabackable
says...
6:34pm Wed 20 Feb 13
little n
says...
6:34pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Nebs
says...
6:39pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Then spot the UK in Figure 10.
We are in deep trouble.
http://www.europarl.
europa.eu/committees
/en/studiesdownload.
html?languageDocumen
t=EN&file=83716
Carnabackable
says...
6:39pm Wed 20 Feb 13
little n wrote:You can't count one as an exception to the rule...
there is a council house not far from me, that has been empty for nearly a year, the old lady that lived there passed away,and her daughter who owns her own house has put in for this council house,claiming that she lived there with her mum,all lies, the fraud department was informed of this months ago,yet she still has the keys and still dosnt live there ,so get them to explain that one ,as i cant understand it
Eric the Red
says...
7:01pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Soouthchurch59
says...
7:18pm Wed 20 Feb 13
A bespoke banner for the bigots....
stopmoaning1
says...
7:21pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Eric the Red wrote:But it did take a full council meeting to work it out!
Well done Basildon Council - the penny has dropped at last! As Basil Fawlty said "Speciality, the bleeding obvious!"
Cosmo Spring
says...
7:46pm Wed 20 Feb 13
stopmoaning1 wrote:someone's got to eat all those pies
Eric the Red wrote:But it did take a full council meeting to work it out!
Well done Basildon Council - the penny has dropped at last! As Basil Fawlty said "Speciality, the bleeding obvious!"
Ironman
says...
7:53pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Soouthchurch59 wrote:why don't they publish the real, detail figures of how many on the list are actually immigrants.
'Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels'
A bespoke banner for the bigots....
benfleet101
says...
8:54pm Wed 20 Feb 13
rty.org.uk/manifesto
s/1959/1959-labour-m
anifesto.shtml
Carnabackable
says...
9:10pm Wed 20 Feb 13
benfleet101 wrote:That was a tactical and economical move, to rid the burden from councils of dilapidated properties, under the guise of offering tenants the chance, to become owners..
Agreed it was Margaret Thatcher who implemented the Right to Buy scheme nationally (after persuasion from Tory Horace Cutler), however, they took the idea from the Labour Party 1959 Manifesto. http://www.labour-pa
rty.org.uk/manifesto
s/1959/1959-labour-m
anifesto.shtml
benfleet101
says...
9:35pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Carnabackable wrote:Ah, so the Labour party were out to con the public? I see. ;)
benfleet101 wrote:That was a tactical and economical move, to rid the burden from councils of dilapidated properties, under the guise of offering tenants the chance, to become owners..
Agreed it was Margaret Thatcher who implemented the Right to Buy scheme nationally (after persuasion from Tory Horace Cutler), however, they took the idea from the Labour Party 1959 Manifesto. http://www.labour-pa
rty.org.uk/manifesto
s/1959/1959-labour-m
anifesto.shtml
DogsMessInLeigh
says...
9:53pm Wed 20 Feb 13
SpiffSpaffington1984 wrote:In one spiffspaff,there would be plenty more housing if the immigrants where taken out of the equation.
Why are immigrants on the council housing waiting list? If they cant afford to pay rent, they are not contributing enough to this country, they have no reason to even be here, and if they are immigrants then they have no local connection to basildon.
Soouthchurch59
says...
10:18pm Wed 20 Feb 13
Ironman wrote:Exactly. It simply wouldn't suit their agenda.
Soouthchurch59 wrote:why don't they publish the real, detail figures of how many on the list are actually immigrants.
'Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels'
A bespoke banner for the bigots....
Dids
says...
11:29pm Wed 20 Feb 13
SpiffSpaffington1984 wrote:HEAR HEAR,Spot on,they should be the last to be considered if at all.
Why are immigrants on the council housing waiting list? If they cant afford to pay rent, they are not contributing enough to this country, they have no reason to even be here, and if they are immigrants then they have no local connection to basildon.
perini
says...
8:36am Thu 21 Feb 13
Dids wrote:Dids - You're right! They should not even be considered, their home country can provide them with housing and if they want to come here then they should expect to support themselves.
SpiffSpaffington1984 wrote: Why are immigrants on the council housing waiting list? If they cant afford to pay rent, they are not contributing enough to this country, they have no reason to even be here, and if they are immigrants then they have no local connection to basildon.HEAR HEAR,Spot on,they should be the last to be considered if at all.
Nebs
says...
11:47am Thu 21 Feb 13
perini wrote:Or we could let them carry on coming here, give them a home, give them benefits, give them medical treatment, and give the bill for all of it to their home country.
Dids wrote:Dids - You're right! They should not even be considered, their home country can provide them with housing and if they want to come here then they should expect to support themselves.
SpiffSpaffington1984 wrote: Why are immigrants on the council housing waiting list? If they cant afford to pay rent, they are not contributing enough to this country, they have no reason to even be here, and if they are immigrants then they have no local connection to basildon.HEAR HEAR,Spot on,they should be the last to be considered if at all.
perini
says...
12:55pm Thu 21 Feb 13
Nebs wrote:Gets my vote!
perini wrote:Or we could let them carry on coming here, give them a home, give them benefits, give them medical treatment, and give the bill for all of it to their home country.Dids wrote:Dids - You're right! They should not even be considered, their home country can provide them with housing and if they want to come here then they should expect to support themselves.SpiffSpaffington1984 wrote: Why are immigrants on the council housing waiting list? If they cant afford to pay rent, they are not contributing enough to this country, they have no reason to even be here, and if they are immigrants then they have no local connection to basildon.HEAR HEAR,Spot on,they should be the last to be considered if at all.
Alekhine
says...
3:25pm Thu 21 Feb 13
Soouthchurch59 wrote:or perhaps council are simply not allowed by law to release the information in that form.
Ironman wrote:Exactly. It simply wouldn't suit their agenda.Soouthchurch59 wrote: 'Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels' A bespoke banner for the bigots....why don't they publish the real, detail figures of how many on the list are actually immigrants.
little n
says...
3:42pm Thu 21 Feb 13
Carnabackable wrote:like mice, where there is one ,there are more.
little n wrote:You can't count one as an exception to the rule...
there is a council house not far from me, that has been empty for nearly a year, the old lady that lived there passed away,and her daughter who owns her own house has put in for this council house,claiming that she lived there with her mum,all lies, the fraud department was informed of this months ago,yet she still has the keys and still dosnt live there ,so get them to explain that one ,as i cant understand it
whataday
says...
3:54pm Thu 21 Feb 13
Soouthchurch59 wrote:the word should have been realists not bigots
'Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels'
A bespoke banner for the bigots....
jolllyboy
says...
5:10pm Thu 21 Feb 13
this was why in 'the old days' support was only given to those whose residence for years was in that parish and they were returned or asked to return to their parish of settlement.
Stop giving child benefit if the children live abroad.
Soouthchurch59
says...
6:16pm Thu 21 Feb 13
Blame those that you elect; not those you can't eject!
Soouthchurch59
says...
6:30pm Thu 21 Feb 13
Alekhine wrote:'IMMIGRATION, teenage pregnancies and family break-ups'
Soouthchurch59 wrote:or perhaps council are simply not allowed by law to release the information in that form.
Ironman wrote:Exactly. It simply wouldn't suit their agenda.Soouthchurch59 wrote: 'Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels' A bespoke banner for the bigots....why don't they publish the real, detail figures of how many on the list are actually immigrants.
Out of the three reasons given above, I note that the Echo chose to focus their attention on the immigration aspect when it came to the headline.
Shameless....
Soouthchurch59
says...
6:38pm Thu 21 Feb 13
whataday wrote:I should know, what it should read!
Soouthchurch59 wrote:the word should have been realists not bigots
'Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels'
A bespoke banner for the bigots....
Ironman
says...
11:52pm Thu 21 Feb 13
Soouthchurch59 wrote:Well said, Sir.
I doubt there is a person among you, that if in the same position, wouldn't take advantage of any prospect of a better life for yourself and children.
Blame those that you elect; not those you can't eject!
iknowbetter
says...
12:43am Fri 22 Feb 13
Ironman wrote:I also agree.
Soouthchurch59 wrote:Well said, Sir.
I doubt there is a person among you, that if in the same position, wouldn't take advantage of any prospect of a better life for yourself and children.
Blame those that you elect; not those you can't eject!
The government should be charging the immigrants country of origin for the full cost of their stay if they are not in work and paying their own way.
whateverhappened
says...
8:49am Fri 22 Feb 13
Soouthchurch59 wrote:Have you ever tried to get into America,Canada, or Austrailia for a better life, not just a case of turning up and demanding benefits i believe.
I doubt there is a person among you, that if in the same position, wouldn't take advantage of any prospect of a better life for yourself and children. Blame those that you elect; not those you can't eject!
Carnabackable
says...
9:20am Fri 22 Feb 13
whateverhappened wrote:You don't get into Aussie without 5 grand in your bank account, a clean record, and a profession, useful to their economy.
Soouthchurch59 wrote:Have you ever tried to get into America,Canada, or Austrailia for a better life, not just a case of turning up and demanding benefits i believe.
I doubt there is a person among you, that if in the same position, wouldn't take advantage of any prospect of a better life for yourself and children. Blame those that you elect; not those you can't eject!
s00s93
says...
9:51am Fri 22 Feb 13
and you know the worse thing, the plot of land behind the hospital, including the local riding school, livery yard and competition centre is going to be knocked down and built houses on....not any old houses that can be used to house people who need it, or even at a reasonable price for first time buyers, but 4-5 bedroom luxury houses with landscapped gardens!!!
Devils Advocate
says...
6:34pm Fri 22 Feb 13
benfleet101 wrote:A little diversity in operation here? Without the Labour party how many council houses do you think would have been in existence, and do you remember how many people were living in the asbestos ridden Nissen huts under private landlords?
Agreed it was Margaret Thatcher who implemented the Right to Buy scheme nationally (after persuasion from Tory Horace Cutler), however, they took the idea from the Labour Party 1959 Manifesto. http://www.labour-pa
rty.org.uk/manifesto
s/1959/1959-labour-m
anifesto.shtml
Lastlaugh...
says...
9:58pm Fri 22 Feb 13
whataday wrote:Real bigots...I think id have to agree with you!
Soouthchurch59 wrote:the word should have been realists not bigots
'Homes crisis blamed on immigration levels'
A bespoke banner for the bigots....
RICH:;CAROL
says...
10:58am Sat 23 Feb 13
Do we need to keep being told the problem, we already know the problem. It needs someone to say enough is enough and sort this debacle out and STOP anymore immigrants coming in and taking our homes. What party is going sort it and NO do not mention BNP as they are a racist party, but one of the others should be putting this issue first on there manifesto.
2shedsjackson
says...
12:08pm Sat 23 Feb 13
.
Only certain people from abroad are eligible for council housing. The rules are very complicated if you are not a UK citizen and your rights will depend on your immigration status. Most people from abroad (including virtually all asylum seekers) do not qualify for council housing.
.
Still why let the facts get in the way of a racist rant.
RICH:;CAROL
says...
12:23pm Sat 23 Feb 13
2shedsjackson wrote:Please explain. There are 9 asylum seeker families in Vange that arrived November and December and they have already been housed by the Basildon council. Please explain also that 3 migrants families from Eastern Europe who arrived here October have been given houses in Felmores and vange this Month ?
Extract from "Shelter " website . Are people from abroad eligible for a coucil house?
.
Only certain people from abroad are eligible for council housing. The rules are very complicated if you are not a UK citizen and your rights will depend on your immigration status. Most people from abroad (including virtually all asylum seekers) do not qualify for council housing.
.
Still why let the facts get in the way of a racist rant.
There are 68 English families on the Basildon council waiting list since April 2012 and since then 23 immigrant families including Congolese Somalian Iraqie Lithuanian and an Egyptian family been housed and all these did not arrive in the UK until september 2012.
Please explain because I would like to know as you seem to know everthing and will be able to tell me and all the other readers WHY ?
2shedsjackson
says...
3:51pm Sat 23 Feb 13
.
As to your request that I enlighten you, I am not aprised of the FACTS relating to these tenants circumstances . Are you or is this just more racist BNP propaganda?
.
Maybe you work in the Housing Department and have access to their case files?
Nebs
says...
8:05pm Sat 23 Feb 13
2shedsjackson wrote:If Rich Carol is right then it would seem that Shelter are wrong.
Unlike most of the racist rants on this site I merely posted an extract from Shelter which states the rules and probability for obtaining a council house, rather than speculation and opinion..
.
As to your request that I enlighten you, I am not aprised of the FACTS relating to these tenants circumstances . Are you or is this just more racist BNP propaganda?
.
Maybe you work in the Housing Department and have access to their case files?
2shedsjackson
says...
7:12am Sun 24 Feb 13
RICH:;CAROL
says...
10:50am Sun 24 Feb 13
Nebs wrote:I will only give you facts on all matters. I only tell truths What I have told you are exact numbers. Shelter is funded by the government and rely on donations and they will only print things that makes them look good and justifys them raking in big money. I do not believe anything that they say.
2shedsjackson wrote:If Rich Carol is right then it would seem that Shelter are wrong.
Unlike most of the racist rants on this site I merely posted an extract from Shelter which states the rules and probability for obtaining a council house, rather than speculation and opinion..
.
As to your request that I enlighten you, I am not aprised of the FACTS relating to these tenants circumstances . Are you or is this just more racist BNP propaganda?
.
Maybe you work in the Housing Department and have access to their case files?
It annoys me very much that some of you keep quoting the BNP . I think the echo should ban anyone that supports a racist nazi party as this bnp are very offensive to many people including me as my daughter as you know married a Jewish man. Some people call others on this site racist and 99% of them are not. Some people turn this post into a racist rant and should not do this.
barneydrop
says...
1:00pm Sun 24 Feb 13
2shedsjackson
says...
1:42pm Sun 24 Feb 13
.
families from Eastern Europe who arrived here October have been given houses in Felmores and vange this Month ?
.
68 English families on the Basildon council waiting list since April 2012 and since then 23 immigrant families including Congolese Somalian Iraqie Lithuanian and an Egyptian family been housed and all these did not arrive in the UK until september 2012.
So please do tell , what is the source of your detailed facts and precise numbers for these families?
2shedsjackson
says...
1:56pm Sun 24 Feb 13
.
I eagerly await your post on the provenance for your facts. Just stating that what you post is the truth doesn't cut it i'm afraid.
jolllyboy
says...
7:15pm Sun 24 Feb 13
Devils Advocate
says...
8:53pm Sun 24 Feb 13
jolllyboy wrote:Whilst agreeing with the meat of your viewpoint, I think the time must be near when mothers take the responsibility of their decision not to marry, and then have children that will be kept by the state. They are old enough to have children then they are old enough to pay for their upkeep. This endless granting of cheque books at our expense to people who keep on having unprotected sex has got to stop.
if you havent lived in the area for 5 years then you should not get a house. Single mothers should not be given a house or separate accommodation than that they were in before getting pregnant. Time for the errant fathers to be made to pay up and the mothers name them or lose benefit.
Altravista
says...
9:56pm Sun 24 Feb 13
Devils Advocate
says...
11:14pm Sun 24 Feb 13
Altravista wrote:How do you actually know the reasons why there are 4000 people on the waiting list? Do you know all about overcrowding, living in shared accommodation, living in houses that are not suitable for human habitation? People sharing separated accommodation? condemned housing?
Are there 4,000 people sleeping rough on the streets of Basildon? No. So why are there 4,000 on the waiting list? If you take out people who are already adequately housed and only stay on the list "as a matter of principle", (yes they exist I know some of them) then the numbers will be greatly reduced. The council could do with analysing these numbers a lot more closely, contacting everyone on the list to assess if they really do have a pressing need for housing. Somehow I doubt it. What might alleviate the situation would be a crackdown on illegal subletting and a requirement for any single person or couple living in a property of more than 2 bedrooms to move to a smaller one, thus leaving larger flats and houses for families. Also closer checks in the first place as to the prospective tenants' family situation - there are countless numbers who claim to have larger families than they actually do, just to get a bigger house.
There are many reasons that people are put on to the waiting list and not all of them obvious.
To say "they are not sleeping on the streets" and "as a matter of principle" shows an oversimplified view, probably from someone not from the working class. As for "moving to a smaller house" that is a bit cruel I think. Without considering your circumstances, would you like it if you had a 4 bedroom house someone knocked at your door and said "Right, your property is too large for your circumstances, you have to move into a 1 bedroom flat!" Of course not. But then of course, you probably live in your own property, as do I, but is that any reason to under occupy in these hard times? Wouldn't it be better if the selfish classes paid everybody a decent living wage and enabled every working person to buy their own property? It would raise the living standards of all of us and allow for a huge increase in the number of employed. Trouble is, the fatted cats want everybody else to work for peanuts then moan when things like this happen. The government stated that we are desperately short of skilled workers, so wedged open the door to that sector of immigration. If they hadn't disbanded apprenticeships (once again out of greed) we would not have had this gap. No matter which way one looks at these problems, it always comes down to mismanagement.
2shedsjackson
says...
7:12am Mon 25 Feb 13
I will only give you facts on all matters. I only tell truths What I have told you are exact numbers.
.
I am still awaiting where these facts originate from, perhaps they are not facts after all and are rumour and propaganda. To know the exact dates of arivals and housing circumstances of some 3 dozen families in another part of the county to where you live seems odd to me.
parallax
says...
9:41pm Mon 25 Feb 13
Maybe RICH:;CAROL has access to info but cant reveal the source so as to implicate themselves (ie whistle blowing)
like our MP's you can believe the data they spout or take a walk down any highstreet or housing estate and see the REAL situation.
Its time we faced up to the FACTS that we cannot afford to pay out to all and sundry unless they can show a history of contributions into the system.
there will be nothing left in the pot when we want to retire let alone when our children need help .
The Rothschild Cowgirl
says...
9:25am Tue 26 Feb 13
parallax wrote:Perhaps we should all emmigrate to shorten the waiting list. Let those who remain support us in our new life of leisure. No need to work , just live off the social benefits afforded us by those hard grafting fools back home.
2sheds
Maybe RICH:;CAROL has access to info but cant reveal the source so as to implicate themselves (ie whistle blowing)
like our MP's you can believe the data they spout or take a walk down any highstreet or housing estate and see the REAL situation.
Its time we faced up to the FACTS that we cannot afford to pay out to all and sundry unless they can show a history of contributions into the system.
there will be nothing left in the pot when we want to retire let alone when our children need help .
Now then, what time was that flight ?
Devils Advocate
says...
9:18pm Tue 26 Feb 13
The Rothschild Cowgirl wrote:"No need to work , just live off the social benefits afforded us by those hard grafting fools back home. Now then, what time was that flight ?"
parallax wrote:Perhaps we should all emmigrate to shorten the waiting list. Let those who remain support us in our new life of leisure. No need to work , just live off the social benefits afforded us by those hard grafting fools back home.
2sheds
Maybe RICH:;CAROL has access to info but cant reveal the source so as to implicate themselves (ie whistle blowing)
like our MP's you can believe the data they spout or take a walk down any highstreet or housing estate and see the REAL situation.
Its time we faced up to the FACTS that we cannot afford to pay out to all and sundry unless they can show a history of contributions into the system.
there will be nothing left in the pot when we want to retire let alone when our children need help .
Now then, what time was that flight ?
Have you actually ever seen a hard grafting person? By which I mean someone who does not sit in a Revolving chair tapping comments onto various newspapers or social networks, doing what passes for earning a living?
I think that there are far too many people in this country who actually believe they earn a living. I am not talking about gamblers on the stock market, but people who leave the job dirty, sweaty, hungry and in need of a stiff pint. why does everybody blame the out of work for the countries ailments? How many of those in Basildon moved here because that's where the work went, only to be let down by useless, do nothing management. That is where you should look for the reason so many are unemployed, those that lived off the backs of the workforce did not do their share of the graft and keep us all gainfully employed!
Cosmo Spring says...
5:12pm Wed 20 Feb 13